Accounting Qualifications Compared: ACA vs ACCA vs CIMA

ACA, ACCA and CIMA compared, with AAT as a starting point: how each UK accounting qualification is structured, what experience it requires, where it leads and how to choose between them.

Abstract illustration of rising bars representing career progression

Key points

  • ACA (ICAEW), ACCA and CIMA are the three chartered routes most often compared in the UK; each combines examinations, practical experience and ethics.
  • ACA is traditionally earned through a training agreement with an authorised employer, often in audit or practice.
  • ACCA is the most flexible and internationally portable; CIMA specialises in management accounting and business finance.
  • All take around three to four years alongside work, and all are respected by employers.

“Accountant” is not a protected title in the United Kingdom, but “chartered accountant” and the designations of the professional bodies are. Employers recruiting for finance roles usually ask for one of them, or for progress towards one. Choosing a route early matters because the bodies differ in how you train and in the work they prepare you for.

The main qualifications at a glance

ACAACCACIMA
BodyInstitute of Chartered Accountants in England and WalesAssociation of Chartered Certified AccountantsChartered Institute of Management Accountants
DesignationChartered Accountant (ACA, later FCA)Chartered Certified Accountant (ACCA, later FCCA)Chartered Global Management Accountant (ACMA, CGMA)
ExaminationsThree levels, culminating in a case studyUp to 13 exams across Applied Knowledge, Applied Skills and Strategic Professional, with exemptions for relevant degreesOperational, Management and Strategic levels, each with objective tests and an integrated case study
Practical experienceAt least 450 days with an ICAEW authorised training employer36 months in a relevant role, signed off against performance objectivesThree years of relevant experience, assessed through a portfolio
Typical settingAccountancy practice, audit, tax, corporate financePractice, industry, public sector, worldwideIndustry and commerce: management accounting, planning, business partnering
FlexibilityTied to a training agreementStudy while in any relevant job; widest choice of optionsStudy while in any relevant job
Summary of each body’s published requirements. ICAEW introduced a redesigned ACA syllabus in 2025, and ACCA has announced changes to its qualification from 2027; check current structures before registering.

How to choose

Where do you want to work?

  • Audit and public practice. ACA is the traditional route and dominant in the large firms, which also train ACCA and ICAS students. Signing statutory audit reports requires a recognised audit qualification and registration; ACA and ACCA can both lead there.
  • Industry finance. CIMA is designed for management accounting: budgeting, costing, performance and strategy. ACCA and ACA holders work in industry in large numbers too.
  • Public sector. CIPFA specialises in public finance.
  • Scotland and Ireland. ICAS and Chartered Accountants Ireland award the CA designation with similar standing to the ACA.
  • International mobility. ACCA has the largest global footprint. All the chartered bodies have mutual recognition agreements with certain overseas institutes, but local practice rights, particularly for audit, depend on national rules.

How do you want to train?

ACA normally requires a training contract with an authorised employer, which brings structured support, paid study leave and a defined timetable, and competition for places. ACCA and CIMA let you start independently, choose your own pace and change employer freely, at the price of more self-direction.

What is your starting point?

  • School leavers. AAT (Association of Accounting Technicians) qualifications are a recognised entry point and earn exemptions from parts of the chartered syllabuses. Apprenticeships combine paid work with study.
  • Graduates. Any degree is acceptable; accounting and finance degrees can earn exemptions from early papers.
  • Career changers. ACCA and CIMA are easiest to begin without first securing a trainee post.

Government funding rules for higher-level apprenticeships in England changed in 2026, restricting funding for Level 7 programmes largely to younger entrants. If you plan to qualify through an apprenticeship, confirm the current position with the employer.

Time, cost and difficulty

Expect three to four years from a standing start, studying alongside full-time work. Costs comprise registration and annual subscription, examination fees and tuition, which is the largest element if you use a training provider. Many employers pay fees and grant study leave, often with a clawback if you leave soon after qualifying. Pass rates for the final-level papers of all three bodies are published and show that a meaningful proportion of candidates need more than one attempt; steady, planned study matters more than background.

After qualifying

Members must complete continuing professional development each year and follow their institute’s code of ethics. Running your own practice requires a practising certificate, professional indemnity insurance and supervision for anti-money laundering purposes. See professional indemnity insurance.

The work itself is changing. Automation is absorbing routine processing, and employers increasingly value data skills, systems knowledge and commercial judgement; see AI in finance teams. Regulatory change, from Making Tax Digital to e-invoicing, sustains demand for qualified advisers.

Frequently asked questions

Which qualification is hardest?

All are demanding. They differ in emphasis and in how training is organised more than in difficulty.

Can I switch between bodies?

Exemptions are available between them for papers already passed, though not always one for one.

Do I need a degree?

No. Each body has entry routes for school leavers, often through AAT or an apprenticeship.

Is one better paid?

Pay follows role, sector and location far more than the letters after your name.

The bottom line

Choose ACA if you want a structured start in practice, CIMA if your interest is in the finance of running a business, and ACCA if you want flexibility and portability. Then commit; finishing matters more than which one you pick.

Important: Syllabuses, experience rules and fees change. Confirm current requirements with the professional body before registering.

Sources and further reading

Scroll to Top